Managed vs Unmanaged Switches: Cisco Catalyst 9200 Series

Introduction

In the world of computer networks, Cisco switches are like traffic directors that help data flow smoothly from one device to another. Cisco is a well-known networking company that offers a series of switches, but one of the most standout series of catalyst switches is known as the Cisco Catalyst 9200. These switches come in two types: managed and unmanaged. Managed switches give network administrators a lot of control over how data moves around, while unmanaged switches are simpler and easier to set up. The Cisco Catalyst 9200 series is popular because it's reliable and has lots of features to help businesses stay connected. Whether you need a switch for a small office or a huge company, there's likely a Cisco 9200 switch that fits your needs. Let's look at the differences between managed vs unmanaged switches in the Cisco Catalyst 9200 series to discover which one could be best for you.

What are the Cisco 9200 Series switches?

The Cisco Catalyst 9200 Series is a series of powerful switches designed to meet modern networking requirements. These switches function as traffic directors for your computer network, ensuring that data flows swiftly and securely. They are equipped with capabilities to help organizations of various kinds, from small offices to major enterprises. The Cisco Catalyst 9200 Series delivers lightning-fast connectivity, dependable performance, and enhanced security capabilities to protect your network from cyber threats. These switches can easily handle video streaming, file sharing, and video conferencing. Furthermore, they are simple to set up and administer, making them ideal for enterprises that require high-performance networking without the hassle. 

Managed Switches in Cisco Catalyst 9200 Series

Managed switches, as the name suggests, offer administrators full control over network traffic. They provide advanced features such as VLAN support, Quality of Service (QoS), and security protocols like SNMP and SSH. These switches, such as the Cisco C9200-48P-E and Cisco C9200-24P-A, come equipped with features like VLAN support, Quality of Service (QoS) settings, and advanced security protocols. With a managed switch, network administrators can customize and prioritize data flow, ensuring that critical applications receive the necessary bandwidth while maintaining security across the network. Additionally, managed switches support Layer 3 routing, allowing for more intelligent routing decisions within the network. These switches are suitable for businesses of all sizes, from small offices to large enterprises, seeking robust network management capabilities to optimize performance and security. With the Cisco Catalyst 9200 Series managed switches, businesses can confidently build a reliable and scalable network infrastructure that can adapt to their evolving needs.

Table 1. Lists the managed switches of the C9200 switches below:

Unmanaged Switches in Cisco Catalyst 9200 Series

On the other hand, unmanaged switches operate with plug-and-play simplicity, requiring minimal configuration. They are typically used in smaller networks where simplicity and cost-effectiveness are prioritized over advanced features. These switches are ideal for small to medium-sized businesses that require basic networking capabilities without the need for complex configurations. One example is the Cisco 9200L-24T-4G-E, which features 24 Gigabit Ethernet ports and 4 SFP ports for flexible connectivity options. Another option is the Cisco 9200L-48T-4G-E, which provides 48 Gigabit Ethernet ports and 4 SFP ports, making it suitable for larger networks with more devices. These unmanaged switches offer plug-and-play functionality, allowing users to simply connect their devices and start networking without the need for extensive setup or configuration. With their affordable pricing and reliable performance, Cisco Catalyst 9200 Series unmanaged switches are an excellent choice for businesses looking for straightforward networking solutions.

Table 2. Lists the managed switches of the C9200 switches below:

Characteristics of Managed and Unmanaged Cisco 9200 Series Switches

Managed Switches

• Advanced Configuration: Managed Cisco switches like the C9200 and C9200L-24T-4G-E offer advanced configuration options, allowing network administrators to customize settings to suit their specific requirements, such as setting up VLANs for departmental segregation or configuring QoS for voice and video traffic prioritization.
• Remote Management: With managed switches, such as the C9200 and C9200L-24T-4G-E, network administrators can exercise their control from anywhere, offering a level of convenience and flexibility that empowers them to monitor and configure the network at their convenience.
• Traffic Control: Managed switches offer features such as Quality of Service (QoS) and VLAN support, allowing administrators to prioritize and control traffic flow for optimal network performance.
• Enhanced Security: Managed Cisco 9200 switches come with advanced security features such as access control lists (ACLs), which are a set of rules that control network traffic and can be used for security purposes, port security, and encryption. These features ensure network integrity and protect against unauthorized access.
• Monitoring and Reporting: Managed Cisco switches like the C9200-48P-E provide detailed monitoring and reporting capabilities, allowing administrators to track network usage, diagnose problems, and generate reports for analysis and troubleshooting.

Unmanaged Switches

• Plug-and-Play Setup: Unmanaged Cisco switches such as the C9200L-24T-4G-E are designed for easy installation and operation, requiring minimal configuration. Simply plug in the devices, and they start working immediately.
• Simplicity: Unmanaged Cisco switches, like the C9200L-24T-4G-E, are designed with a straightforward setup and operation, providing a reassuringly simple solution for small businesses or home networks that don't require advanced features.
• Cost-Effectiveness: Unmanaged Cisco switches, like the C9200L-24T-4G-E, are not just simple to use but also offer a budget-friendly option for basic networking needs, instilling confidence in their cost-effectiveness.
• No Remote Management: Unlike managed switches, unmanaged Cisco switches do not support remote management capabilities. Configuration changes must be made directly on the device.
• Limited Scalability: Unmanaged switches may have limited scalability compared to managed switches, making them suitable for smaller networks with fewer devices and more straightforward requirements.

When looking to buy or purchase Cisco switches like the C9200 series, businesses should consider these characteristics to determine which option best suits their networking needs

Comparison between Managed and Unmanaged Switches

When comparing managed vs unmanaged switches, several factors come into play. Managed switches offer better performance, security, and scalability compared to unmanaged switches. However, they are also more complex to configure and typically come at a higher price point. Some comparison tables are written below to differentiate between managed and unmanaged Cisco 9200 switches.

Different Specifications of Managed and Unmanaged Switches

Table 3 highlights the key specifications and differences between a managed switch (C9200-48P-E) and an unmanaged switch (C9200L-24T-4G-E) in the Cisco 9200 series.

PoE+ Power Supply Difference

Table 4 compares the PoE+ power with primary and secondary power supplies for managed and unmanaged network witches in the Cisco 9200 series:

Stacking Options

Table 5. highlights the differences in stacking options between managed vs unmanaged switches in the Cisco 9200 series switches. Managed switches offer advanced stacking capabilities, allowing for easier management, scalability, and redundancy. On the other hand, the unmanaged switches do not support stacking.

Performance Specifications

Performance specifications are crucial factors to consider when choosing between managed and unmanaged switches. Managed switches typically offer higher switching capacity, faster forwarding rates, and lower latency compared to unmanaged switches. Additionally, managed switches often support advanced features such as Quality of Service (QoS) and Layer 3 routing, providing greater control and flexibility for network administrators.

Table 6. highlights the differences between the performance specifications of managed and unmanaged switches in terms of switching capacity, forwarding rate, latency, quality of service (QoS), layer 3 routing, VLAN support, security features, network management capabilities, scalability, reliability, and cost.

Physical Specifications

The physical specifications of C9200 series switches include compact dimensions, typically measuring around 1.73 inches in height and varying widths and depths depending on the model. 

Table 7. provides the differences between managed and unmanaged switches in the Cisco 9200 series in terms of size, weight, temperature range, humidity, and other relevant factors.

Configuration Differences

Configurations refer to the settings and options available on a network switch that determine its behavior and functionality. Managed switches offer extensive configuration capabilities, allowing administrators to fine-tune network performance, implement security measures, and manage traffic efficiently through features like VLAN support, Quality of Service (QoS), and advanced routing protocols. In contrast, unmanaged switches typically have limited or no configuration options, making them simpler to set up but lacking the flexibility and control of managed switches.

Table 8. highlight the differences between managed and unmanaged switches in the Cisco 9200 series in terms of their capabilities for network management, security, and advanced features.

Bandwidth Specifications

Table 9, outlining the bandwidth specifications of managed and unmanaged switches in the Cisco 9200 series:

Security Features

Managed switches offer significant security benefits, but they also put you in the driver's seat. You have the ability to monitor and control the network, swiftly shutting down active threats. They ensure data protection, control, and management plans. The security features are diverse, ranging from network communication encryption to access control lists that effectively keep unauthorized users out. VLANs can also be leveraged to grant temporary or limited access to your network to individuals who should not have it. It's important to note that managed switches provide extensive control over your network, which can be a challenge for some. Conversely, Cisco unmanaged ethernet switches feature basic security, ensuring no weaknesses from system to system, and accessories such as a locking port cover can prevent interference. For example, the different security features are compared below in Table 10.

Price Comparisons

In general, managed switches in the Cisco 9200 series tend to be priced higher than their unmanaged counterparts due to their advanced features and greater control options. However, unmanaged switches offer a more budget-friendly option for businesses with simpler networking needs, providing cost savings without sacrificing basic functionality.

Table 11. compares the price of managed and unmanaged switches in the Cisco 9200 series:

Speed Features

Table 12. provides an overview of the speed features of managed and unmanaged switches in the Cisco 9200 series, including switching speed, port speed, uplink speed, forwarding rate, latency, PoE availability, and throughput.

Scalability Features

Table 13. highlights the differences between managed and unmanaged switches in the Cisco 9200 series, with managed switches offering more options for expanding and scaling your network infrastructure.

Set-Up Without Cost

Unmanaged ethernet switches, such as the Cisco C9200L-24T-4G-E and C9200L-24P-4X-E, offer a hassle-free setup without cost. Unlike managed switches, unmanaged switches don't allow users to manage or configure their LAN. Instead, they provide a fixed network configuration, making them straightforward to use. This simplicity makes unmanaged switches popular among startups with minimal data exchange needs. While managed switches such as C9200-48P-E and C9200-24P-E enable users to construct new local networks, isolate smaller devices, and efficiently manage traffic, unmanaged switches lack such advanced functionality. However, they still ensure basic connectivity without the complexity of configuration. So, for businesses seeking a simple and cost-effective networking solution, unmanaged Ethernet switches like those in the Cisco C9200 series offer an excellent choice.

Safety Functions

The safety functions of managed C9200 switches are fortified with advanced security features such as access control lists (ACLs), port security, and encryption protocols. These robust measures are designed to safeguard against unauthorized access and protect sensitive data. Additionally, managed switches offer features like DHCP snooping and IP Source Guard to mitigate various network attacks, providing a strong defense to ensure the integrity of the network infrastructure.

However, unmanaged C9200 switches lack these advanced security functions, leaving them more vulnerable to security breaches and unauthorized access. While they do provide basic protection against network threats, such as MAC address filtering and loop prevention, they do not offer the same level of granular control and security management as managed switches. Therefore, managed switches, with their advanced security features and enhanced control, may prove to be a more effective option for businesses that require robust security measures and compliance with industry regulations in order to enhance network safety and mitigate potential risks.

New vs. Refurbished Cisco 9200 Series Switches

When deciding between new vs refurbished Cisco 9200 Series switches, whether managed or unmanaged, organizations should compare the advantages of purchasing new equipment, such as the newest features, warranties, and manufacturer support, against the cost savings of refurbished switches. New switches provide peace of mind with guaranteed performance and reliability, but reconditioned switches can provide a cost-effective choice without sacrificing quality, making them appropriate for environments with limited budgets or secondary network requirements. However, it is critical to ensure that refurbished switches are certified and thoroughly tested to guarantee they match industry standards and performance requirements.

Where to Buy Cisco Catalyst 9200 Series switches?

If you're looking to purchase Cisco Catalyst 9200 series switches like the C9200 or C9200L-24T-4G-E, you have several options available. One convenient way to buy these switches is through authorized Cisco vendors. These vendors offer genuine Cisco products and provide reliable customer support to assist you with your purchase. Additionally, you can explore online marketplaces where Cisco switches are sold. Before making a purchase, be sure to compare prices and check seller ratings to ensure a smooth buying experience. Whether you need a C9200-48P-E for your office network or a C9200L-48P-4G-E for your small business, researching where to buy from trusted sources will help you find the best deal. So, where to buy? Consider authorized vendors and reputable online marketplaces for your Cisco Catalyst 9200 series switch needs.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, choosing between managed and unmanaged switches in the Cisco Catalyst 9200 series depends on your network needs and priorities. Managed switches offer advanced features such as VLAN support, Quality of Service (QoS) management, and Spanning Tree Protocol (STP), which provide greater control over network traffic. These features are particularly beneficial in complex networking environments where customization and security are paramount. However, they come at a higher price and require more expertise to configure and manage. On the other hand, unmanaged switches offer reassuring simplicity and cost-effectiveness, making them an ideal choice for smaller networks with basic connectivity requirements.

In the end, considerations like network size, financial constraints, and the required degree of control and security should be taken into account when choosing between managed and unmanaged switches. By carefully considering these factors and understanding your specific requirements, you can confidently make a decision that best suits your organization's needs and goals, ensuring the optimal performance of your network.

Related Topic:

Managed vs Unmanaged Switches: How to Choose the Best Network Switch

Why Upgrade to the Cisco Catalyst 9200 Series Switches?

Cisco 9200 VS 9300 series switches: Head-to-Head Comparison

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What are the main differences between managed and unmanaged switches?

A. Managed switches offer advanced features and greater control over network traffic, while unmanaged switches are simpler and easier to deploy.

Q. Can I upgrade from an unmanaged to a managed switch later?

A. Yes, it is possible to upgrade from an unmanaged to a managed switch, although it may require additional configuration and expertise.

Q. Is there a significant price difference between managed and unmanaged switches?

A. Managed switches typically come at a higher price point than unmanaged switches due to their advanced features and capabilities.

Q. How do I know if my network requires a managed switch?

A. If your network requires advanced features such as VLAN support, QoS, or security protocols, a managed switch may be necessary.

Q. Are there any security risks associated with unmanaged switches?

A. Unmanaged switches lack the security features of managed switches, making them potentially more vulnerable to unauthorized access and attacks.